The Lancaster MP has questioned the need for the proposed redesign of local government.
Labour’s Cat Smith said she was ‘sceptical’ about the devolution plans, which could see all 15 local councils across Lancashire, including Lancaster City Council, replaced with a single regional authority and an elected mayor, similar to those seen in other areas of the North West such as Manchester and Liverpool.
Currently, Lancaster City Council is responsible for some local services such as bin collections, local planning, street cleaning and council housing.
Other local services fall under the remit of Lancashire County Council, including highways, social care, libraries and school admissions.
Under the proposals, the government wants to merge areas where there are currently two tiers of local authority - smaller district and larger county councils - to streamline services.
Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner said the moves would give areas more powers over housing, transport, education and employment, and it would help drive economic growth and investment.
Opponents to the move say the formation of so called ‘mega councils’ could actually reduce the amount of decisions made locally.
The Member of Parliament for Lancaster and Wyre grilled the Minister for Housing, Communities and Local Government on the issue in House of Commons this week.
Ms Smith said: ‘’The Minister in his statement said this was the end of a top-down approach by central government. But to many of my constituents this looks like a one-size-fits-all approach, which works in Greater Manchester, but doesn’t necessarily work in rural counties.
‘’So what assurances can the Minister give my constituents, and me, that this will not be imposed on local areas against their will and how will he measure consent from a local area that this is the approach they want?’’
In response, Jim McMahon MP said: ‘’We don’t accept at all that the one-size-fits-all argument any more than to say that councillors work in some areas and not others, (or) Members of Parliament work in some areas but not others.
‘’In the end, Mayors, when given powers and resources, can achieve change in partnership with local leaders.
‘’We are not cresting super councils, we are creating a single strategic authority that gives power from this place downwards and allows councillors to have far more power.’’
Lancashire has already engaged in adopting devolution, and earlier this year, plans were unveiled to create a Combined County Authority for the county, with the aim of addressing years of historically low investment in the area and providing a platform for accelerated growth.
These ‘Level 2’ plans would provide a single body for the whole of Lancashire to champion its interests, deliver on local priorities and provide greater local accountability and decision-making powers.
‘’What I can say in Lancashire is that in our drive to widen devolution areas across the country, the principal there is for foundation authorities,’’ added Mr McMahon.
‘’Lancashire has already agreed to a Level 2, which in the White Paper, would be the equivalent of a foundation authority, and in that sense, already has devolution in place.’’
Commenting after the discussion in parliament, Ms Smith added: ‘’The Lancaster and Wyre constituency area I represent has 246 elected officials. One MP, one Police and Crime Commissioner, 8 county councillors, 42 district councillors, and 194 parish councillors.
‘’Do we need another tier of local government with a Lancashire Mayor? I'm very sceptical, and I was pleased to lead a debate on this recently.’’
‘’I'm really concerned about top-down changes to local democracy being imposed on our area without measurable consent. Crucially here, the Minister also admitted it himself, Lancashire already has the mayoral-equivalent of local decision making.’’
Lancaster animal shelter launches 'Big Build' fundraiser to help save charity
LISTEN: Morecambe "definitely submitting a bid" to become first UK Town of Culture
Heysham Port upgrade blamed for traffic chaos 'trapping residents in their homes'
LISTEN: Tourism champs hail Eden Project and Tour de France as huge for Morecambe Bay area
Donation helps college pan ability football team to play in national championships
LISTEN: Meet the new manager of the Midland Hotel in Morecambe
LISTEN: Main contractor to build Eden Project Morecambe to be announced this month
£1.2m of funding for flood defence schemes in Lancaster district announced
Morecambe Bay hospital trust unveils new painless blood test
Thousands raised to help boost return of Lancaster Music Festival
High street computer games shop in Lancaster closes down
LISTEN: Carnforth actor wins Hollywood and Paris awards for horror film role
"1600 potholes repaired last week" says councillor as roads debate rumbles on
Burger King takeaway in Lancaster city centre closes down
Morecambe lifeboat crew reunite dog lost on sands with owner
New Morrisons Daily supermarket opens in Morecambe
Council investigate after derelict food trailer found dumped in Lancaster layby
Man charged after pedestrian died in Morecambe hit and run
LISTEN: We go out on Pothole Patrol in Morecambe
Award success for Lancaster and Morecambe's talented musical theatre stars
